A cozy listening break for grown-ups
Whiskerville Listening Corner
Episode 02 · 02:13 · Oliver & Sophie
A Clue or a Guess?
An empty biscuit plate and a cat under the table: is the mystery solved? Join Oliver and Sophie for a playful way to separate what we notice from what we guess.
Try it together: Choose a picture-book illustration. Take turns saying “I notice…” and “I wonder…”—then look for a clue that could help you check your guess.
AI-generated hosts and audio. Created for parents, caregivers, and educators. Recorded ahead of Nina’s November 18, 2026 release.
Read “A Clue or a Guess?” transcript
Oliver: Welcome to the Whiskerville Listening Corner. I’m Oliver. Today’s mystery is A Clue or a Guess? Sophie, there’s an empty biscuit plate, and a cat under the table. Case closed! The cat took the biscuit.
Sophie: Hello, I’m Sophie. Hold on, Detective Oliver! You’ve noticed an empty plate and a cat. But did you see the cat take anything? A clue is something we notice that might help explain a mystery. A guess is our idea about what happened.
Oliver: So the empty plate is something I can see. Saying the cat ate the biscuit is a guess. Let’s try a pretend mystery together. A yellow bookmark has disappeared from a book on the sofa. A cushion is on the floor, with a corner of yellow paper peeking out from underneath.
Sophie: Here are two statements. One: I can see yellow paper under the cushion. Two: someone hid the bookmark on purpose. Which one describes something we can see, and which one is a guess? Pause us here if you’d like a moment to talk it over.
Oliver: The first statement describes what we can see. The second is a guess about why it happened. And we still don’t know whether that yellow paper is the bookmark! Our next step could be to lift the cushion gently and check. A good detective doesn’t have to be right straight away.
Sophie: Exactly. Perhaps it’s the bookmark. Perhaps it’s a shopping list. And finding the bookmark still doesn’t tell us how it got there. We can say, I changed my mind because I found a new clue. Changing your mind can be good detective work.
Oliver: Here’s a little game for your next reading time. Choose an illustration together. Each person names one thing they can see, then one thing they wonder. Try: I notice a muddy footprint. I wonder who walked here. Give everyone a turn, and keep your guesses kind. No blaming the nearest cat!
Sophie: Especially a cat who might simply be having a nap. Nina’s next adventure, The Mystery of the Mayor’s Medal, is planned for November eighteenth. Until then, practise with any picture book at home. I’m Sophie, with Oliver. Thanks for visiting the Whiskerville Listening Corner. Keep noticing, keep wondering, and leave room for a new clue.

Episode 01 · About 3 minutes
Turn Read-Aloud Time into a Little Detective Game
Join Paul and Clara for three gentle questions you can try during storytime. No worksheets. No quiz. Just a chance to notice, guess, and talk together.
AI-generated hosts and audio. Created for parents, caregivers, and educators. Transcript below.
Try these questions at storytime
- What did you notice?
- What makes you think that?
- Did anything change your mind?
Follow your child's interest. It's fine to skip the questions and simply enjoy the story.
Read the episode transcript
Paul · 0:00
Welcome to Whiskerville Listening Corner. I'm Paul.
Clara · 0:05
And I'm Clara. We are so glad you're joining us today.
Paul · 0:09
In today's episode, "Turn Read-Aloud Time into a Little Detective Game", we're talking about how picture books are already full of wonderful little secrets waiting to be found. Turning storytime into a gentle detective game can make reading aloud feel like a cozy, shared adventure.
Clara · 0:29
It really can! And you don't need any special worksheets or practice drills. It is all about asking three simple, open-ended questions.
Paul · 0:43
The first question is simply asking, "What did you notice?"
Clara · 0:48
Exactly. Before jumping to conclusions, pause on an illustration. Maybe there is a muddy footprint on the path or a garden gate left unlatched. Instead of asking "who did it?", just invite your child to spot whatever catches their eye.
Paul · 1:03
Right, because there are no wrong answers! Noticing the color of a character's boots or a little bird in a tree is just as wonderful as spotting a clue.
Clara · 1:14
That leads so naturally to the second question: "What makes you think that?"
Paul · 1:21
Oh, I love that one. If a child says, "I think the puppy took the mitten!", you can warmly ask what made them think so.
Clara · 1:31
And they might say, "Because look! There are little paw tracks right next to the mitten basket!" It gently invites them to share their imaginative reasoning without feeling tested or put on the spot.
Paul · 1:43
And when the story takes a fun turn, you get to ask the third question: "Did anything change your mind?"
Clara · 1:52
Yes! Say you discover later in the story that the puppy was sleeping upstairs all afternoon. You can pause and say, "Wait a second, the puppy was napping! Did anything change your mind about who moved the mitten?"
Paul · 2:07
That normalizes changing your guess when new information appears. It shows children that updating our ideas is just what real detectives do.
Clara · 2:20
The best part is keeping it completely low-pressure. Playful wrong guesses are just a chance for shared laughter and lighthearted curiosity.
Paul · 2:30
If you are looking for stories like this, families can look for Whiskers & Clues: Nina, the Cat Detective by Jonia Epp. It’s a gentle illustrated cozy mystery series for ages five to nine.
Clara · 2:44
It is a lovely example of the kind of age-appropriate mystery families can explore together.
Paul · 2:51
Thank you so much for listening to Whiskerville Listening Corner today.
Clara · 2:55
Happy reading, everyone, and enjoy playing detective together!
Transcript supplied with the original audio export. Timestamps are approximate.
Ready to investigate with Nina?
Whiskers & Clues: Nina, the Cat Detective brings gentle illustrated mysteries to readers ages five to nine.